My two favorite memoirs of all time—Jeannette Walls’s The Glass Castle and Frank McCourt’s Angela’s Ashes—go minimalist on the titles. No subtitles, no appendages, just three words for Walls and two for McCourt. The good stuff waits inside. So when I heard that a book by Steven Starring Grant, a writer from down the road in Blacksburg, had won the Library of Virginia’s literary award in nonfiction for a memoir titled Mailman: My Wild Ride Delivering the Mail in Appalachia and Finally Finding Home, I was dubious. There on the cover of the book is the entire arc of his story. I could imagine a Southwest Virginia version of All Creatures Great and Small except with parcels and envelopes substituting for farm animals. But the reviews had been favorable, and I thought I should at least check out the opening pages of what I expected to be a whimsical tale of eccentric postal customers brandishing guns behind their moonshine stills or offering snacks of RC Cola and Moon Pies, so I bought a copy. I’m so glad that I did. I’d been completely wrong in judging this book by its title. Steven Starring Grant is not only a hell of a writer, but he’s a thinker, too. He’s the kind of guy you’d want to join on a road trip or have at your table for a dinner party. He can go deep, and at times he can be as mystical as Annie Dillard, as confessional as St. Augustine, as political as Frederick Douglass, and as deadpan funny as Christopher Buckley. His book deserves that prize.
Grant lost his executive-level job during the early days of the covid pandemic and needed to make sure that he, his wife, and their two daughters would not go without health insurance, and when he heard that rural postal carriers enjoyed insurance benefits from their first day on the job, he applied. On the most fundamental level Grant gives us a peek behind the curtain, a backstage pass to those rooms where all the action occurs out of our sight as we stand at the post office counter. He educates us in the demanding expectations of postal workers as they sort, organize, pack, and deliver the mail. One of pleasures of reading a stranger-in-a-strange-land story is that we readers get to follow our narrator as he enters a bewildering world and must learn how to survive in it.
Grant tells this story in a tone that fluctuates from sincere admiration for the old-timers who mentored him to mordant self-deprecation to unabashed slapstick. At times he channels Calvin Trillin and Roy Blount, Jr., as he does here in discussing his love of coffee: “On a cold day, if you had boiled an old sock filled up with Folgers in a hubcap, I’d have drunk it and thanked you for it.” At his most hilarious he simply quotes a disgusted colleague who is overwhelmed by all the Amazon packages generated by customers who don’t want to venture out during the pandemic: “Every goddamned time I turn around there are more boxes of bullshit macaroni and cheese and fucking Hamburger Helper and every other goddamned thing because these motherfuckers are too big a bunch of pussies to drive to the fucking Kroger and I’m driving three hours every day to sort this shit because they’re a bunch of pussies and this post office sucks one big donkey cock, did anybody tell you that?” But he can be a loving admirer of hardscrabble heroism, too, as when he encounters an elderly woman, living alone remotely, who raises chickens to support herself. He meets her after he lugs a heavy sack of chicken feed to her barn: “When this mountain woman handed me those eggs for my family and said ‘God bless you,’ something twanged inside me. Instead of getting choked up in front of a stranger, I just touched the brim of my hat and got back into my truck while my composure still held. For the rest of the day everything else was as light as a feather. I’d have carried chicken feed for her every day of my life. It was my great privilege to do it as her mailman.”
Another memoir I’ve read recently is Patrick O’Connell’s Main, Middle, and Gay: A Chef Finds His Place in the World Against All Odds. I guess in this case we have to forgive the marketing-driven synoptic subtitle just because the primary title is so cryptic. O’Connell is the chef at the Michelin-starred Inn at Little Washington; Main, Middle, and Gay are the three streets that circumscribe the primary plot of land occupied by the Inn. They also allude to the “odds” mentioned in the subtitle. As a child O’Connell was strikingly effeminate, much to the bewilderment of his straight, mainstream father and siblings. His story is a classic American upward mobility tale that hits its stride when it eventually reaches the history of how O’Connell and his partner and lover, Reinhardt Lynch (here given a pseudonym) established and gradually developed the Inn into a destination for gourmands from around the world. I’ve been to the place several times, and I’ve even met O’Connell in the kitchen. I’ve never had anything but an extraordinary time at that magical place. But I have to confess that this rags-to-riches story, with its outcome never in doubt, didn’t grab me as much as Steven Starring Grant’s riches-to-rags story did.